What I thought was the third of three novels, until the last page. Coming soon, fourth book, Rapture! This was my favorite book of the series so far. I think these books would make great movies. (Is that a good thing to say about a book?)

This is probably my favorite book of the series. I love how she gets to visit all of these different places to learn first-hand what Daniel goes through for her and how much they're meant for each other no matter what. Was not anticipating the little gargoyle, but I like the outside-the-box thinking on that point. Five. Stars.

I loved the first and second books, and yes I wante to know about Lucy's past and the curse. But this book is very tiresome, I'm 3/4 done and it's been days, usually I can finish a book in a couple of hours. I feel like this should have been a companion book rather than a part of the series. I hope the final book is as good as the first and second :(

Great series. Loved the first and second books. I wasn't exactly a humongous fan of this book though. I still can't wait for the last and final book!

best book in the whole series!!!!

I loved this book! I was so ticked when I finished it, I didn't want it to end! I seriously will be counting down the days till the next one comes out!

Why is it never here at my branch?!?! I want to read it!

read first 1 can't wait to get started!

I found the book hard to get into at first but after chapter five I started to enjoy it. it did get a bit repetative. I did like the glimpse to show us what happened with Cam to show why he chose the way he did.I enjoyed the ending with all of the group gathered together at the cabin. I am holding out hope that the last book will be wonderful to make up for these books sorta dragging on. I hope the last one wraps the storyline up and somehow they all can be a family again and that its done it a way that makes all the books worth the read. I was left with a lot of unanswered questions about who Luce really is, how the curse is overcome, what role the nephilim will play in re-writing history and how the star shots really work.I can't wait to find out more about Cam's origin. ***minor spoiler alert*** I always assumed Daniel met Luce (the first one) after he fell but if he chose her while still in Heaven how did he know her to love her? was she an angel or just a mortal he watched? if that's true how did she love him back? that question was never really answered and I really hope it is answered in the last book. Anyone have any ideas?

The more of these books i read the more it seems 2 drag on and the less sure i am if i like the series or not....